Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Seahawks Trade for TE Kellen Winslow

Solheim Cup - Epilogue

DUNSHAUGHLIN, IRELAND - SEPTEMBER 25:  Azahara Munoz of Europe lifts the trophy following her team's victory during the singles matches on day three of the 2011 Solheim Cup at Killeen Castle Golf Club on September 25, 2011 in Dunshaughlin, County Meath, Ireland.  (Photo by Ian Walton/Getty Images)

Make no mistake - I am not blaming Ryann O'Toole for the Americans' loss yesterday.  She just happened to be the one without a chair when the music stopped.  A lot of other people's shortcomings placed Ryann in the situation where she absolutely had to hang on - and she couldn't.  Michelle Wie was 1-up with three holes to go and lost outright (I know - Suzann Pettersen made a terrific run to win the match).  Angela Stanford had two decent chances to win holes down the stretch and couldn't.  Juli Inkster absolutely pissed away a half-point.  O'Toole collected three points in her four matches this week and is by no means the reason the U.S. lost the Solheim Cup.

Star-divide

Here are the individual records for each player (ordered by winning percentage, then points won):

Europe

Gustafson

Matthew

Pettersen

Hedwall

Munoz

Nordqvist

Davies

Boeljon

Stupples

Hjorth

Reid

Gal

W-L-T

4-0-0

2-0-2

3-1-0

2-1-1

2-1-1

2-2-0

1-1-1

1-2-0

1-2-0

1-3-0

1-3-0

0-2-1

U.S.A.

Pressel

O'Toole

Kim

Creamer

Kerr

Lincicome

Hurst

Lang

Lewis

Wie

Inkster

Stanford

W-L-T

4-0-0

2-0-2

1-0-1

3-1-1

2-2-1

2-2-0

1-1-0

1-3-0

1-3-0

1-3-0

0-2-1

0-3-0

The first thing that leaps out at me - Christina Kim only made two starts?  I applaud Rosie Jones' decision to keep starting O'Toole once Ryann established herself but as my sister-in-law says, "Jeezum Pete"!  If I had been able to Solheim blog as in years past, I would have been barking about Christina's omission all weekend.  Other than Creamer and Inkster, Kim has historically been the Americans' best match player.  And as you can see, she did nothing this weekend to change that history.  As I said yesterday, Cristie Kerr was playing well through her pain but she certainly did her team a disservice by not emphasizing that pain to Jones the first two days.  Sitting Kerr a couple of times to help ensure her availability on Sunday would have certainly given Kim another start or two with absolutely no dropoff in match-play ability.  This might not be entirely fair, but I'm now willing to state that Kerr's failure to disclose the extent of her discomfort is the biggest single reason the U.S. did not win.

UPDATE:  It has come to my attention that not only did I grossly overstate Kerr's responsibility for this situation in those stricken-through sentences, the assumption that there was any lack of communication between Kerr and Jones is completely unfounded.  Accounts exist that there was complete and constant communication on Kerr's condition all week long.  All parties agreed to keep playing Kerr as long as she was able.  In hindsight, we may still argue that Jones should have rested Kerr at some point but there is no basis for my "failure to disclose" statements. 

I chose to strike-through the lines rather than delete them entirely because I have one big publishing rule - if I'm sure my words have been seen by a substantial number of people, I won't allow myself to "take them back" as if I had never said them.  If I leave my foot in my mouth too long, I have to live with it.

My two players to watch both had good weeks but while Pettersen stepped up at crunch time, Brittany Lincicome could not.  She missed a crucial five-footer at 10 to go 2-down to Christel Boeljon and though she won the next hole when Christel bogeyed, Brittany couldn't give herself enough chances to get even.

I don't know if Paula Creamer could have beaten Catriona Matthew yesterday but I damn sure know she would have lasted longer than 13 holes had she gotten a little rest on either Friday and Saturday.  BTW - note that nobody on Team Europe played more than four matches while Creamer and (officially) Kerr played five for the U.S.  This confirms my preview observation that for once, Europe had excellent team depth and they used it properly.

Tremendous weekend for Sophie Gustafson.  Not only did she fashion a perfect record but she overcame her fear of being interviewed by speaking with Golf Channel prior to the event.  Sophie has a severe stutter (which I had not been aware of) and chose this occasion to tape a Q&A.  I can't imagine how difficult this was for her nor how she has been able to cope with performing on the public stage for so long with her impediment.  Thank you Sophie for sharing that long-overdue facetime with us and thanks to Val Skinner and GC for arranging it.

Gustafson gets the MVP over Morgan Pressel because hey, her team won.  As for the Least Valuable Player, I kept going back-and-forth between two possibles but at least Inkster did get a half-point in singles and lost a close one (1-down with Brittany Lang) to Pettersen/Gustafson on Friday.  Angela Stanford (with Stacy Lewis) lost 3&2 to Matthew/Munoz Friday morning, sat out that afternoon and came back with Lewis Saturday morning to get destroyed by Hedwall/Gustafson 6&5.  This got her benched Saturday afternoon - probably for O'Toole since Ryann hooked up with Lewis, which worked to the tune of a 2&1 victory.  Since she was the only player to collect no points and was obviously Jones' choice as being the problem with the Lewis teaming, Angela Stanford gets the LVP.

To keep this Epilogue from getting overly negative, I'll conclude by saying that this competition was the most closely fought ever (the most nerve-racking and down-to-the-wire Solheim I've witnessed, for sure).  I'm not thrilled that I got the result exactly right but as far as the future of the Solheim Cup is concerned, this was probably the way it needed to turn out.  Two years from now when they gather at Colorado Golf Club, no longer will there be calls for format changes or declarations of a mismatch.  I'll take that in lieu of an American victory - this time.

Comment 8 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

More from Hound Dog LPGA

Mizuno Classic - Epilogue

Nov 2011 by hound dog - 1 comment

Comments

Display:

This one certainly raised the question of depth...

Jones sat Pressel for one match and was rewarded with a 4-0-0 record. She played Creamer and Kerr all 5 matches and didn’t have nearly as much luck. Both teams have traditionally played a few players every match. Obviously that isn’t going to work so well anymore! You can’t risk wearing out your best players when you face a fresh deep team.

I’m going to do my own look back at the Solheim Cup, but I’ll gladly toot my own horn as a supporter of the O’Toole pick. I was glad to see her step up and do so well. And I suspect we’re going to see that O’Toole – Hedwall rivalry for quite a while. I think those two were the standouts among the rookies.

HD, do you think maybe we’re already seeing a changing of the guard? It seems to me that, once you allow for the adrenaline, the rookies as a whole actually played better than most of the vets. And it also seems that the less-established rookies — the ones without Tour wins — played better than the ones who had already won. (Hedwall is the obvious exception here. But she won that PowerPlay Golf event earlier this year as well as 3 regular LET events. She’s definitely in a class of her own.)

Mike Southern
www.ruthlessgolf.com

by Ruthless Mike on Sep 26, 2011 8:45 AM PDT reply actions  

Not Hound Dog but...

The changing of the guard is fully underway. It started in 2005 for the USA with Creamer, then in 2007 with Pressel and Lincicome, and continued in 2009 with Wie and Lang and then maybe O’Toole, Lewis, and Hurst in 2011. Who for 2013 ? Thompson, Joh, Johnson ?

For Europe the changing started in 2009 with Nordqvist. For 2011 Hedwall, Reid, Munoz, and Gal all look like they could be repeat players and maybe Boeljon. I have not been as optimistic in pevious years about rookies for Europe being repeat players.

A couple of years ago I read about the coming of the Spanish ladies in european golf. So there may well be more of the Spanish ladies in that changing of the guard. Mozo and Recari maybe, plus Marta Silva the #1 rated college woman player for this year.

by tatkins on Sep 26, 2011 1:45 PM PDT up reply actions  

can't type or use right words today

pevious = previous
do = due in my 2 cents below

by tatkins on Sep 26, 2011 1:55 PM PDT up reply actions  

My 2 cents...

I do not fault Jones for not playing Christina Kim more than she did because Christina has played poorly for the year with a T13 and a T16 as her only 2 tournaments to earn points this year with 7 missed cuts.
I thought the O’Toole captain’s pick was a good one, which based on points won was a good pick.
I do fault Jones for the decision to go with the Stanford/Lewis and Inkster/Lang duos a second time in the foursomes, which she said her instinct told her not to do. That mistake was compounded by playing Kerr in the afternoon because the team was down two points, when she knew Kerr was hurting.
The Hurst/Lincicome duo I thought was a mistake. She should have started Hurst with Creamer or Pressel, someone who would have gotten in her ear and encouraged her, I think Linicome is too quiet and would not get in her face and push her.
Hounddog I thought you knew Gustafson had a stuttering problem as it has been mentioned several times. Even to the point that I am sure I have seen a story about her changing medication for the problem do to the side effect of one medication having a negative effect on her play.
I agree that Stanford gave the most dissapointing performance.
Mel Reid despite her record I thought played very well. She had the misfortune of going against Creamer the first two matches.
I did not expect more out of Wie than she delivered, because she has been playing poorly recently. I thought that Jones should have played Wie less for that reason.

by tatkins on Sep 26, 2011 10:46 AM PDT reply actions  

Your Sunday post did seem to be overly critical of O'Toole

Particularly in comparison to post script on other sites. Good summary this time.

I was calling for more of Christina Kim throughout the event. Passion and energy are particularly vital on the road. I loved Morgan’s response when asked what she told Ryann when they were paired together; “I told her there’s no way we’re losing this match.”

Lang is a problem for the American team because she’s destined to be on future Solheim squads but she doesn’t pair well. I’ve seen more spark in a damp sponge. Pairing Lang with Wie in Saturday four ball instead of Kim with Wie was one of the most bizarre captain’s decisions I can remember, along with sending Lang/Inskter and Lewis/Stanford for a double dose of embarrassment. Wie was actually forced to try to pump up Lang when they fell behind in that match.

BTW, I understand you didn’t see the early sessions. Don’t be fooled by the tight loss of Lang/Inskter on Friday. Pettersen and Gustafson were nervous on the greens, missing 6 putts of less than 6 feet over one stretch. It was a rout other than the scoreboard. Likewise Lewis/Stanford deserved a more lopsided defeat on Friday morning. Munoz had at least a half dozen short or mid range makeable putts that she narrowly missed. They were bunched early in the round. The screen would flash, “Munoz to win the hole,” but after a while you could be comfortable she’d never drain them.

Aza really surprised me later during the matches. I’m glad you used a picture of her atop this post. I’ve viewed her as a cute but moderate player, hardly imposing. Yet this week she hit so many clutch shots, and started making big putts from all distances, that when O’Toole faltered on 17 and suddenly Munoz could change the math by winning 17 against Stanford, I cringed when the camera caught her effortless swing into that green from 120 yards. You could tell immediately she had nailed it. Europe went from underdog to considerable favorite as soon as that ball nestled 3 feet from the cup.

Earlier in the comments, someone proposed Hedwall and O’Toole as future stars. I’m not sure O’Toole will make another Solheim Cup team. That’s one of the reasons I felt so sick for her yesterday. Ryann has two terrific strengths — long confident driving and aggressive effective putting, especially for birdie. On certain courses those strengths allow her to look like one of the best players in the game. The Solheim layout was similar to the US Open track, very long with generous fairways and point and shoot greens. The middle of Ryann’s game can be so flawed that on other courses her weaknesses take over, minimizing her strengths. She’s one of my favorite players but I’d say it’s less than 50/50 she makes the 2013 team on points. Blumenherst has been around a few years and may fulfill her amateur credentials.Then you’ve got Lexi, Jennifer Song, Jennifer Johnson, Tiffany Joh, Jessica Korda, Danielle Kang and several others, all of whom had more consistent and accomplished amateur careers than Ryann, who struggled to make the lineup at powerhouse UCLA. The American youngsters didn’t blossom leading up to 2011 but it easily could be opposite in 2013. Playing Solheim in Colorado fits to Ryann’s strength with the high soaring ball flight. We may be debating her value as a potential captain’s pick once again.

by Awsi Dooger on Sep 26, 2011 4:11 PM PDT reply actions  

O'Toole

So you are suggesting that O’Toole will do nothing to improve the weaknesses in her game. There has been a good number of players who have improved and become winners as they got older. From what I have seen, putting is the hardest part of the golf game to improve and that is not what you say her weakness is. Plus she is very athletic and should be able to develope her game. Besides I used the weasel word (maybe). I do not make predictions, I only look at possibilities and probabilities and the LPGA courses are mostly setup to favor the big hitters. That is why most dominate players are big hitters.

by tatkins on Sep 26, 2011 5:59 PM PDT up reply actions  

I'm the one who suggested O'Toole and Hedwall may become a rivalry...

Ryann needs to work more on her strategy, and then the skill improvements will come.

I think O’Toole has the tough skin necessary to succeed. After a certain point, skill is secondary to the mental game. She’ll be able to tough through the steep learning curve Tour life requires. In the end, it’s the ones who don’t give up that finally end up on top.

Mike Southern
www.ruthlessgolf.com

by Ruthless Mike on Sep 27, 2011 1:50 PM PDT reply actions  

pettersen v wei

Preface by saying Wei played well and Pettersen treated the closing holes like her personal dart board.
That said the contrast in demeanor between the two on the closing holes was night/day. Wei’s body language was almost like showy boxer’s in the ring. She charged after tee shot and ran to celebrate with her teammates on 17 green after making bird before Pettersen’s putt. Leading the cheers shouting “you like that?!, you like that?!”. Not a big deal, it was fun to watch, but contrast her composure with the match winner Pettersen. Suzy was calm as I’ve seen her, like a golfer needs to be to insure consistent execution under pressure.
Wei has a long way to go. But hey, don’t we all?
Great match.

by fanslaststand on Sep 27, 2011 7:48 PM PDT via iPhone app reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to Hound Dog LPGA! Whether you're a casual follower of women's golf or a longtime fan, drop by often to check out what's new! Contact me directly at hounddog.lpga@yahoo.com

Recent Posts


Managers

Hound-large_small hound dog

N9102048_32253009_9304_small jamie.r.saengsawang